Skip to content
Secure Shopping. Discreet Shipping. Free US Shipping on orders $75+

Bettys Toy Box is a women-owned, family run sex-positive boutique where pleasure meets confidence, offering body-safe toys, real advice, and a playful space to explore what feels good.

Anal Sex Toys (Butt Plugs, Prostate Massagers, Beads & Lube)

If you're looking to explore the exciting world of pegging, you can try our Anal Safe and Pegging Dildos as well as our Pegging Kits. If you're new to anal play, visit our Anal Play for Beginners. If you're looking specifically to have your prostate stimulated, try our Prostate Massagers and Vibrators department. 


Filters

  • Je Joue Vesta Petite Powerful Remote Control Vibrating Butt Plug

    Original price $109.00 - Original price $109.00
    Original price
    $109.00
    $109.00 - $109.00
    Current price $109.00
    In stock

    Meet Vesta, the silky-smooth vibrating butt plug designed for effortless pleasure and pure, indulgent sensation. Petite, elegant, and surprisingly ...

    View full details
    Original price $109.00 - Original price $109.00
    Original price
    $109.00
    $109.00 - $109.00
    Current price $109.00
  • Je Joue Egon Powerful Remote Control Vibrating Butt Plug

    Original price $129.00 - Original price $129.00
    Original price
    $129.00
    $129.00 - $129.00
    Current price $129.00
    In stock

    Egon takes its name from a word meaning “strong with a sword,” and this beautifully shaped plug lives up to every bit of that legend. Its distincti...

    View full details
    Original price $129.00 - Original price $129.00
    Original price
    $129.00
    $129.00 - $129.00
    Current price $129.00
  • Ring It Remote Control Rimming Vibrating Prostate Plug

    Original price $129.00 - Original price $129.00
    Original price
    $129.00
    $129.00 - $129.00
    Current price $129.00
    In stock

    The Ring It Remote Control Prostate Plug is designed to overwhelm the senses with deep internal vibration and intensely teasing external st...

    View full details
    Original price $129.00 - Original price $129.00
    Original price
    $129.00
    $129.00 - $129.00
    Current price $129.00
  • Romp Luster Set of 3 Graduated Butt Plugs

    Original price $44.99 - Original price $44.99
    Original price
    $44.99
    $44.99 - $44.99
    Current price $44.99
    In stock

    The Romp Luster butt plug set lets you start out small and work your way up - a perfect introductory set for anybody beginning their anal explorati...

    View full details
    Original price $44.99 - Original price $44.99
    Original price
    $44.99
    $44.99 - $44.99
    Current price $44.99
  • Frenzy Pressure Sensing App-Controlled Butt Plug

    Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00
    Original price
    $69.00
    $69.00 - $69.00
    Current price $69.00
    In stock

    Frenzy is going to drive you wild with its ribbed details, vibration and delicious rotation. Designed to fit your body's inner contours, Frenzy is ...

    View full details
    Original price $69.00 - Original price $69.00
    Original price
    $69.00
    $69.00 - $69.00
    Current price $69.00
  • Aneros Eupho Syn V Vibrating Silicone Prostate Massager with Remote

    Original price $119.00 - Original price $119.00
    Original price
    $119.00
    $119.00 - $119.00
    Current price $119.00
    In stock

    The Aneros Eupho Syn V takes the legendary Eupho shape and enhances it with deep, powerful vibration designed to intensify every contraction, movem...

    View full details
    Original price $119.00 - Original price $119.00
    Original price
    $119.00
    $119.00 - $119.00
    Current price $119.00
  • Rimmers Textured Rotating Rimming Butt Plug with Remote

    Original price $89.00 - Original price $89.00
    Original price
    $89.00
    $89.00 - $89.00
    Current price $89.00
    Low stock

    For lovers of a great rim job and tons of booty sensation, this Rimmers plug has you covered. The tapered tip is easy to insert and the ridged text...

    View full details
    Original price $89.00 - Original price $89.00
    Original price
    $89.00
    $89.00 - $89.00
    Current price $89.00
  • Aqua Jet Vibrating Powered Anal Douche - Ultra Hygienic

    Original price $79.00 - Original price $79.00
    Original price
    $79.00
    $79.00 - $79.00
    Current price $79.00
    Out of stock

    The Aqua Jet is a premium anal douche that will make your prep time easy, thorough, and enjoyable. The customizable 3-speed jet pressure system has...

    View full details
    Original price $79.00 - Original price $79.00
    Original price
    $79.00
    $79.00 - $79.00
    Current price $79.00
    Sold out
  • Double Up Fingering Dildo with Slim Width and Suction Cup

    Original price $32.00
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price $32.00
    Current price $28.00
    $28.00 - $28.00
    Current price $28.00
    In stock

    Finger Fest is a fun silicone dildo for anybody who loves that feeling of being fingered. Use it on your partner for a fingering experience that ca...

    View full details
    Original price $32.00
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price $32.00
    Current price $28.00
    $28.00 - $28.00
    Current price $28.00
    Save 13% Save %
  • Charlie Small Thin Sleek 5 inch Pink Silicone Dildo

    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
    In stock

    Whether you're a dildo beginner or looking for something with a smaller profile, Charlie is the dildo for you. The silky smooth surface glides agai...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Morning Dew Thin Small 5 Inch Blue Dildo with Suction Cup

    Original price $18.00 - Original price $18.00
    Original price
    $18.00
    $18.00 - $18.00
    Current price $18.00
    In stock

    This small dildo is perfect for beginners to penetration or anybody who wants a slim dildo with an average length. The beautiful gradient light blu...

    View full details
    Original price $18.00 - Original price $18.00
    Original price
    $18.00
    $18.00 - $18.00
    Current price $18.00
  • My Secret Vibrating Tongue with Finger Loop - Red

    Original price $54.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price
    $54.00
    $54.00 - $54.00
    Current price $54.00
    In stock

    How many licks to drive you wild? This licking tongue vibrator is quiet but powerful with 10 levels and patterns of vibration plus a tongue that gi...

    View full details
    Original price $54.00 - Original price $54.00
    Original price
    $54.00
    $54.00 - $54.00
    Current price $54.00
  • Thumbs Up Shallow Penetration Vibrator with Finger Loop

    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
    In stock

    If it's shallow penetration you crave, Thumbs Up gives you that 'just the tip' feeling and so much more. With two motors, you can snug the textured...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
  • Dr. Tush's After Butt Play Soothing Lotion

    Original price $29.00 - Original price $29.00
    Original price
    $29.00
    $29.00 - $29.00
    Current price $29.00
    In stock

    Dr. Tush is a Betty's favorite for soothing, cooling, and hydrating your delicate skin. Incorporate it as part of your after care or any time you'r...

    View full details
    Original price $29.00 - Original price $29.00
    Original price
    $29.00
    $29.00 - $29.00
    Current price $29.00
  • Odyssey Vibrating Silicone Prostate Massager & Butt Plug

    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
    In stock

    Journey into deeper anal pleasure with the Matrix Odyssey Plug, a sleek vibrating plug designed to deliver satisfying fullness, targeted prostate p...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
  • Jealousy 7 Inch Rippled Red Silicone Dildo

    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price
    $32.00
    $32.00 - $32.00
    Current price $32.00
    Low stock

    If you love the feel of thrusting and tons of sensation without too much girth, you're going to adore Jealousy. The ridges on this flexible silicon...

    View full details
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price
    $32.00
    $32.00 - $32.00
    Current price $32.00
  • Rebellion Small 5.75 Inch Blue Silicone Beginner & Pegging Dildo

    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price
    $32.00
    $32.00 - $32.00
    Current price $32.00
    Out of stock

    Rebellion is a gorgeous shimmery blue dildo with an upwards curve, ridged shaft, and bulbous tip designed to hit a g-spot or prostate just right fo...

    View full details
    Original price $32.00 - Original price $32.00
    Original price
    $32.00
    $32.00 - $32.00
    Current price $32.00
    Sold out
  • Surrender Sleek Ultra Thin 5.75 Inch Blue Silicone Beginner & Pegging Dildo

    Original price $30.00 - Original price $30.00
    Original price
    $30.00
    $30.00 - $30.00
    Current price $30.00
    In stock

    The Surrender Intermediate is a thrilling next step up in pegging, or anal play yet still slim enough for a beginner to vaginal penetration. It fea...

    View full details
    Original price $30.00 - Original price $30.00
    Original price
    $30.00
    $30.00 - $30.00
    Current price $30.00
  • Surrender Small Thin 4.75 Inch Purple Silicone Beginner & Pegging Dildo

    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
    In stock

    The Surrender Slim is a thrilling introduction to dildo play, pegging, or anal play, with a silky smooth, firm yet flexible silicone shaft, comfort...

    View full details
    Original price $24.00 - Original price $24.00
    Original price
    $24.00
    $24.00 - $24.00
    Current price $24.00
  • Njoy Disco Weighted Stainelss Steel Plug

    Original price $180.00 - Original price $180.00
    Original price
    $180.00
    $180.00 - $180.00
    Current price $180.00
    In stock

    For lovers of more extreme anal play or firm g-spot sensations, the Disco is a gorgeous weighted stainless steel plug with all the contours and cur...

    View full details
    Original price $180.00 - Original price $180.00
    Original price
    $180.00
    $180.00 - $180.00
    Current price $180.00
  • Voyager Smooth Vibrating Butt Plug & Prostate Massager

    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
    Out of stock

    The Matrix Voyager Plug is designed to take you deeper into smooth, satisfying anal pleasure with a sleek elongated shape that feels both approacha...

    View full details
    Original price $44.00 - Original price $44.00
    Original price
    $44.00
    $44.00 - $44.00
    Current price $44.00
    Sold out
  • BANG! Rotating & Vibrating Silicone Butt Plug with Remote

    Original price $68.00 - Original price $68.00
    Original price
    $68.00
    $68.00 - $68.00
    Current price $68.00
    In stock

    This little plug delivers big thrills with both vibration and rotation plus a wireless remote control that will bring intense booty bliss. Play sol...

    View full details
    Original price $68.00 - Original price $68.00
    Original price
    $68.00
    $68.00 - $68.00
    Current price $68.00
  • Sweet n Small Thin Beginner 4 Inch Purple Mini Dildo with Suction Cup

    Original price $16.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price
    $16.00
    $16.00 - $16.00
    Current price $16.00
    In stock

    Perfect for anybody who wants a gentler touch, shallow penetration, or who is just started out with exploring toys. This cutie offers 3.75 inches o...

    View full details
    Original price $16.00 - Original price $16.00
    Original price
    $16.00
    $16.00 - $16.00
    Current price $16.00
  • Universal Easy to Use Anal Douche with Silicone Bulb- Black

    Original price $19.00 - Original price $19.00
    Original price
    $19.00
    $19.00 - $19.00
    Current price $19.00
    In stock

    Get ready for the main event! This classic enema/douche is easy to use, easy to assemble, and comes with 2 interchangeable attachments. Get squeaky...

    View full details
    Original price $19.00 - Original price $19.00
    Original price
    $19.00
    $19.00 - $19.00
    Current price $19.00

Frequently Asked Questions About Anal Toys

Anal Toys FAQ

What size anal toy should a beginner start with?

If you're new to anal play, start small and choose a toy with a slim, tapered tip. Beginner-friendly butt plugs or small anal training toys are ideal because they allow your body to adjust gradually. Always use plenty of lubricant and take your time — comfort is key.

Are anal toys safe to use?

Yes — when used properly, anal toys are safe and can be extremely pleasurable. Always choose toys with a flared base for safety, use a generous amount of anal-safe lubricant, and select body-safe materials like silicone. Never use toys not specifically designed for anal play.

What lubricant is best for anal toys?

Water-based lubricant is a great all-around option and is compatible with all toy materials. For longer-lasting glide, many people prefer thicker water-based formulas designed specifically for anal play. Avoid silicone lubricant with silicone toys unless the manufacturer confirms compatibility.

What are the different types of anal toys?

Anal toys come in many styles, including:


  • Butt plugs (for fullness and training)

  • Anal beads (for gradual stimulation)

  • Prostate massagers (curved for targeted internal stimulation)

  • Vibrating anal toys (for added sensation)

Each type offers a different experience depending on your preferences and comfort level.

How do I clean anal toys?

Clean your anal toys before and after each use with warm water and mild soap or a dedicated toy cleaner. Non-porous materials like silicone are easy to sanitize. Always allow toys to dry completely before storing them.

Can anal toys be used for prostate stimulation?

Yes. Prostate massagers are specifically designed to target the prostate (often called the P-spot) and can create deeply pleasurable sensations. These toys typically have a curved shape to apply gentle internal pressure in the right area.

How can I make anal play more comfortable?

Comfort comes down to three things: relaxation, lubrication, and starting small. Go slowly, breathe deeply, and use more lubricant than you think you need. Choosing a beginner-friendly toy with a tapered shape can make the experience smoother and more enjoyable.