Skip to content
Secure Shopping. Discreet Shipping. Free US Shipping on orders $75+
Secure Shopping. Discreet Shipping. Free US Shipping on orders $75+

Betty's Toy Box is a women-owned, family run sex-positive boutique where pleasure meets confidence, offering body-safe toys, real advice, and a playful space to explore what feels good.

Anal Sex Toys (Butt Plugs, Prostate Massagers, Beads & Lube)

If you're looking to explore the exciting world of pegging, you can try our Anal Safe and Pegging Dildos as well as our Pegging Kits. If you're new to anal play, visit our Anal Play for Beginners. If you're looking specifically to have your prostate stimulated, try our Prostate Massagers and Vibrators department. 


Filters

$
$
  • Romp Luster Set of 3 Graduated Butt Plugs
    Romp Luster Set of 3 Graduated Butt Plugs
    Sold out
    $44.99 - $44.99
    $44.99
    $44.99 - $44.99
    $44.99

    Romp Luster Set of 3 Graduated Butt Plugs

    Out of stock

    The Romp Luster butt plug set lets you start out small and work your way up - a perfect introductory set for anybody beginning their anal explorati...

    View full details
    $44.99 - $44.99
    $44.99
    $44.99 - $44.99
    $44.99
    Sold out
  • A hand holds the Rimmers Textured Rotating Rimming Butt Plug with Remote. "Powerful Vibration" is written above. Icons highlight waterproof, body-safe silicone, USB rechargeable, powerful vibration, and remote control features.
    The Rimmers Textured Rotating Rimming Butt Plug with Remote is shown in black, featuring ribbed textures, a flared base, and a matching remote labeled “RIMMERS” with buttons for easy control. Glowing lines highlight its vibrating function.
    $89.99 - $89.99
    $89.99
    $89.99 - $89.99
    $89.99

    Rimmers Textured Rotating Rimming Butt Plug with Remote

    In stock

    For lovers of a great rim job and tons of booty sensation, this Rimmers plug has you covered. The tapered tip is easy to insert and the ridged text...

    View full details
    $89.99 - $89.99
    $89.99
    $89.99 - $89.99
    $89.99
  • A hand holds the Hole Punch Vibrating 3 Piece Anal Training Set: three purple silicone plugs with unique hollow designs and smooth surfaces, each featuring circular handles. A soft pink and purple background enhances these versatile toys' elegance.
    The Hole Punch Vibrating 3 Piece Anal Training Set, featuring three purple cylindrical pieces with circular handles and flat bases, aligns on a gradient purple background. A smaller capsule-shaped item is situated to their left, completing the display.
    $69.99 - $69.99
    $69.99
    $69.99 - $69.99
    $69.99

    Hole Punch Vibrating 3 Piece Anal Training Set

    In stock

    Want to explore bigger and better anal sensations? Hole Punch features 3 top quality silicone plugs with a unique hollow design that transmits vibr...

    View full details
    $69.99 - $69.99
    $69.99
    $69.99 - $69.99
    $69.99
  • A cardboard box featuring the "Betty Box" logo in a retro-style font on one side. Beneath it, an illustration of a woman is complemented by a ribbon reading "Betty's Toy Box." The background boasts a green top adorned with snowflakes and a red bottom, offering a sneak peek into the exciting contents of the Betty’s Boundless Booty Anal Sex Mystery Box - Holiday 2024 Edition.
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00

    Betty's Boundless Booty Anal Sex Mystery Box - Holiday 2025 Edition

    The Holiday 2024 edition of the Boundless Booty box promises a fun holiday twist to this classic anal play kit. Are you an anal beginner or booty c...

    View full details
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00 - $299.00
    $69.00
  • An Aneros MGX Syn Trident Blue Hands-Free Prostate Stimulator, a product from Aneros aimed at promoting prostate health and awareness, is displayed in front of its black packaging. The blue device features a ribbon symbol, highlighting its non-vibrating design and ribbed stem for enhanced prostate stimulation.
    The Aneros MGX Syn Trident Blue Hands-Free Prostate Stimulator by Aneros is a blue silicone prostate massager featuring a curved design with two finger loops at the base for easy handling. The main shaft is smooth and slightly tapered, making it ideal for precise prostate stimulation. This product ensures both comfort and effectiveness.
    $79.95 - $79.95
    $79.95
    $79.95 - $79.95
    $79.95

    Aneros MGX Syn Trident Blue Hands-Free Prostate Stimulator

    In stock

    Want to experience intense prostate orgasms? You will love the MGX Syn Trident from the world leader in prostate stimulation, Aneros. MGX has a sli...

    View full details
    $79.95 - $79.95
    $79.95
    $79.95 - $79.95
    $79.95
  • A red and black box with white accents displays the Aneros branding, marked as the "20 Year Anniversary Edition." Inside, a phthalate-free hands-free prostate stimulator is suggested by the stylized image on the front of the packaging, labeled as "Aneros Original Progasm (Large)," ideal for intermediate users seeking enhanced prostate stimulation.
    The Aneros Original Progasm Hands-Free Prostate Stimulator (Large) by Aneros is a white, ergonomically-shaped device with a smooth, curved design ideal for intermediate users. It features a prominent central axis with bulbous ends and two rounded extensions at the base, perfect for prostate stimulation. The texture is smooth and polished against a plain white background.
    $59.95 - $59.95
    $59.95
    $59.95 - $59.95
    $59.95

    Aneros Original Progasm Hands-Free Prostate Stimulator (Large)

    In stock

    Do you want to feel full while you stimulate your prostate? Progasm is the largest probe by the prostate experts at Aneros, perfect for an interme...

    View full details
    $59.95 - $59.95
    $59.95
    $59.95 - $59.95
    $59.95