Skip to content
Secure Shopping. Discreet Shipping. Free US Shipping on orders $75+
Secure Shopping. Discreet Shipping. Free US Shipping on orders $75+

Bettys Toy Box is a women-owned, family run sex-positive boutique where pleasure meets confidence, offering body-safe toys, real advice, and a playful space to explore what feels good.

Softies Squishy Beginner Butt Plug

Softies Squishy Beginner Butt Plug

by BMS Enterprises
$18.00 - $18.00
$18.00
$18.00 - $18.00
$18.00

Discover comfortable anal play with the Softies 4-Inch Silicone Anal Plug. Its tapered tip and silky-soft, dual-layer silicone make insertion feel smooth and approachable, while the flexible neck provides enough firmness for controlled movement without feeling overly rigid.

The slightly wider neck creates a satisfying sense of fullness, and the flared base keeps the plug securely positioned while providing an easy grip for removal. Soft, seamless and discreet, it’s a welcoming choice for beginners or experienced users who prefer a smaller, squishier plug.

Why you'll love it

  • Soft, squishy dual-layer silicone provides comfortable fullness
  • Tapered shape supports gradual, controlled insertion
  • Flexible neck offers comfortable movement during wear
  • Flared base helps keep the plug safely positioned
  • Seamless construction feels smooth against the body
  • Compact size is approachable for beginners
  • Waterproof design makes cleaning simple

How to use it

Apply a generous amount of water-based lubricant to the plug and anus. Relax your muscles and slowly insert the tapered tip, pausing whenever your body needs time to adjust. Once comfortably positioned, the flared base should remain completely outside the body. Enjoy it during solo or partnered play, and avoid wearing it for extended periods until you understand how your body responds. To remove, add more lubricant if needed, relax and gently pull the plug out using its base. Stop immediately if you experience pain, numbness or discomfort.

Specs

  • Material: Dual-layer silicone
  • Functions/Modes: Non-vibrating
  • Waterproof Rating: Waterproof
  • Power: Not required
  • Colour: Not specified
  • Lubricant Compatibility: Use with water-based lubricant
  • Care: Wash before and after use with warm water and mild soap or a compatible toy cleaner; dry completely before storage
  • Safety: Flared base designed for safer anal play; never insert the base
  • Other Details: Silky-soft finish, tapered head, flexible neck, seamless construction and discreet design

Measurements:  Length: 4 inches Insertable Length: 3.3 inches Width: 1.3 inches in diameter

Discreet, unmarked shipping from our warehouses in Michigan, Arizona, and California.

FREE USA SHIPPING on all US orders $75 and up before tax and after discounts.

The shipping label will not have Betty's Toy Box printed on the outer packaging, nor any logos or branding. We value your privacy and understand the need for discretion.

Our full shipping policy, including international order policies can be found HERE

For a complete guide on toy care and storage, read
How to Clean, Care For, and Store Your Pleasure Products

Make sure to clean your pleasure product after each use to avoid harboring any bacteria.

Dildos/Vibrators/Anal Toys/Toys with electronics: 

  • Clean your toy with mild soap and warm water, making sure to get into every seam.
  • Do not fully submerge unless the toy is waterproof
  • For non-waterproof, spot clean with a damp cloth. 
  • Use a spray toy cleaner for non-waterproof toys or to give your toy a quick clean. 

Stroker Sleeves

  • Remove from the outer casing and thoroughly rinsed with warm soapy water after each use
  • If your stroker sleeve feels tacky after cleaning, dry thoroughly then add a small amount of pure cornstarch or Renewal Powder - FOUND HERE

Harnesses/Straps: 

  • Spot clean with a damp cloth

FOR SPOT CLEANING, USE A DEDICATED TOY CLEANER - FOUND HERE

Always dry completely with a lint-free towel before storing, and keep toys in a clean, dry place away from direct sunlight or dust.



Sex toys come in an astounding array of materials, and we at Betty's want you to know exactly what you are putting in, around, and on your body.

That is why we have created this comprehensive Guide to Sex Toy Materials to help you make the best choice for your body.